October 19, 2003

Landslide


A river runs through it. Landslide at Derrybrien, south Galway.


A couple of months ago, I was driving along the road near Nephin Beg. The sun was setting, so I stopped to take a photograph of a turf stack, nestling in the blooming heather, with the mountain in the background. I strolled about 30 metres off the road across the flat stretch of peat, which was cracked from the dry weather. I could feel the ground tremble as I walked over it, so when I had taken the snap, I stamped on the ground to see how much it would shake. Except the ground didn't shake. It rippled, as if it was as thick as the skin on a bowl of custard. I tiptoed off the bog like Wiley E Coyote (scientifically proven as the only way to walk on a surface that can't support you. FACT).


It was yet another reminder that bogs are essentially very large bodies of water, only just held together either by a mixture of spagnum moss, existing peat, geological characteristics and other vegetion. And because bogs are also rather delicate, the effect of disturbing the equilibrium of plant and mineral life can be rather dramatic. A few weeks ago, there was a landslide in Pollatomish, Co. Mayo, where huge stretches of bog detached itself from the mountain and rolled downhill - it was a miracle that no-one died. Even as the investigation into the cause of that landslide continues when, on Friday, another landslide occurred in south Galway. In the Sliabh Aughty hills, near the village of Derrybrien (about 15 minutes south of Loughrea), a river of peat, mud and not a few trees came crashing down a riverbed, covering fields, partially surrounding an old farmhouse and slowly heading for the nearby road.


There are many parts of Ireland which are both desolate and beautiful. The Sliabh Aughty hills are more desolate than beautiful, forming a barrier between the soggy fields of south Galway, the prosperous plains of Munster to the south and the exposed stone fields of the Burren to the west. To the east, the hills roll down to the banks of Lough Derg and the Shannon. A millenium ago, Brian Boru hid in the oak forests of the area (Derrybrien - Doire - oak), harried the Vikings that had invaded the country and used the area to build up a powerbase that eventually led to his crowning as High King in 1002. Today, the oak forests are but a memory - the hills are covered completely in growing bogs and forestry plantations of conifers, and there are few houses or farms to be seen along the boreens of the mountains. It is rumoured that the IRA had a training camp there (though that rumour seems to exist for every mountain range in Ireland) and one could certainly hide plenty there. It seems an ideal place to build a windfarm, and indeed, a 70 turbine farm is under construction near Derrybrien village. So the question being asked is if the construction work and the landslide are somehow connected.



You can see the cracks in the road, which is used by the heavy vehicles building the windfarm nearby.


I set off early to Derrybrien yesterday to see the landslide for myself. A thick fog covered the hills, reducing visibility to no more than ten metres, and when I reached the "Road blocked" signs, I parked the car and started walking. As the road ascended, a sharp wind whipped the fog across the road.



Entrance to windfarm.

After a mile or so, I passed the entrance to the wind farm. Even on a clear day, it's not visible from any road. I continued along the road, and one could see how the heavy machines had cracked and shattered the road. A while later, a fully-laden truck thundered out of the fog up the entrance, groaning under the strain of a hauling tons of gravel up to the site. Later, another huge earthmover passed by, disappearing behind me into the gloom. After two miles, I had nearly reached the end of the road and reckoned that access to the landslide had to be from another road. I walked back. I drove around to Derrybrien by another boreen, and after asking for directions, discovered that I had been on the right road after all. I must have been only a few yards away from the site earlier. Damn!



The road from Derrybrien to the site of the landslide, blocked off to traffic.


I drove back to the blocked road (from the other, Derrybrien side), parked the car and started walking again. The locals all opened the barrier, and drove up, but at this stage, the fog had burned off, and the sun felt warm. After about a kilometre, I reached the site of the landslide. I had walked right past earlier, but in the fog, I couldn't see it.



The landslide was discovered on Friday, following the path of a river bed and had reached the deserted farmhouse. By yesterday morning, it had advanced (more slowly) towards the road. The workmen were using the two digging machines to dig a dyke which, when filled with boulders, would halt the flow before it reached the road.



The slide on Fridayhad been accompanied with a lot of water (according to the locals) but there was no sign of any flooding yesterday. In the following pic, the workman is trying to ascertain the rate of flow (either that or she was just staring at the ground for an awfully long time).



At the bridge on the road, the workmen had placed large straw bales to protect the bridge if the rubble got that far. So did the work on the windfarm cause the slide ? Well, the source of the slide was a good distance up the hill, quite close to the site. The foundation for each turbine is about the depth of a two-story house, and cuts through the layer of bog to the underlying rock. In addition to the constant shaking of heavy trucks and earthmovers, there has certainly been a lot of disturbance to the bogland in the area. There was a team from the windfarm evaluating the situation and it looks like they will bring more engineers in to help later this week.



Posted by Monasette at October 19, 2003 03:06 PM
Comments

Checking out Derrybrien on the internet for other reasons and came across your article. Just curious to know who you are? I have lived in Derrybrien for 18 years and love the area especially the Slieve Aughty mountains and where I have walked regularly with my dog in all weathers snow, rain and sunshine and it is beautiful and peaceful with wonderful views. Congratulations on your news update and photos. I feel very saddened by what has happened. Such a large scale development has never been built on bog before so nobody can foretell the consequences - besides the obvious one of losing our beautiful Slieve Aughties to development.

Posted by: Berna Morgan at October 20, 2003 03:22 PM

The Sliabh Aughties are certainly looking beautiful at the moment, with both the heathers and trees turning gold and brown. It looks like the windfarm was the culprit for the landslide - god knows what will happen when it starts raining on the area that has already collapsed.

/John

Posted by: John at October 23, 2003 10:10 PM

I live near Derrybrien and it was reported this morning that the main Portumna - Gort road was blocked as a result of further landslides. Yet, I can't find anything on the net..

Sarah

Posted by: Sarah at October 30, 2003 04:04 PM

I live near Derrybrien and it was reported this morning that the main Portumna - Gort road was blocked as a result of further landslides. Yet, I can't find anything on the net..

Sarah

Posted by: Sarah at October 30, 2003 04:04 PM

The RTE website have given it a bit of coverage, as well as AA Roadwatch. And here, of course...

/John

Posted by: John at October 30, 2003 10:36 PM

Like Berna Morgan I am intrigued to know who you are. I found your report informative and useful.

Posted by: Edward Somerville at November 1, 2003 08:59 AM

I have visited the location this morning and followed the course of the polluted river as close as I could down to Lough Cutra. The water is extrtemely polluted. The Shannon Regional Fisheries Board reported today that over 100,000 fish have been killed in the river. Personally, I find this figure difficult to believe, although the river now definetely holds no life, it was not densely populated with fish. The water usually is peaty and stained and quite acidic having run off the mountain bogs. While contrasted with the Peterswell (Opposite) side of the range the difference in colour is remarkable. I can only hope that Lough Cutra will act as some form of Natural filter and prevent the Beagh river, which flows out of the lake, and has a healthy trout population from becoming polluted as the local Kilbacenty anglers have control of this stretch and look after it. Incidentally, I believe local people are spot on in contributing the damage to the wind farm operation. Reports I have heard suggest that the foundation holes for the turbines had continually filled with water. In order for the steel fixing to be facilated this water was wrecklessly pumped out onto the surrounding bog and not channelled into the rivercourse or as would be both easy and sensible. With the movoment of heavy machinery and the blasting of rock in the immediate vicinity by ASCON for roadbuilding on site, the delicate environment was compromised. Hibernian/ESB have made no comment to date in regard to this Disaster. Some serious questions have to be answered. Where was the Environmntal Impact Report? Was one issued before planning was granted for this operation? Is there planning permission for these quarries to be in operation on the side of the mountain? Did the Engineers on site comply with regulations in regard to the release of thousand of cubic meters of water onto a open bogland resulting in the bog becoming overweight and sliping down the valley. The place is a terrible mess and I can only hope that the Environmental Protection Agency and the Fishery Boards severely fine the company and individuals responsible. I like to say the place could be cleaned up and put right but realistically, you would have to see the absolute mess to believe the extent of the damage.

Posted by: phil donoghue at November 3, 2003 03:51 PM

and as for the 'multi million pound tourist & fishing industry' at lough Cutra...it sounds like an insurance scam in the making to me..I've necer seen evidence of it in all my years in the area!

Posted by: pudsy at November 7, 2003 07:02 PM

Alas the slide at Derrybrien is another case of man forcing his will on the land and the environment. People are looking for scientific reports to explain the cause of the slide, the company who has been contracted to provide this report has been engaged by the Wind farm company, Hibernian Wind Farms, not exactly an independent report. In either csae they will deal with and examine only issues above the surface and will ignore the subtle energy from the movement of underground streams, which influence the character of surface water, lightning and huricanes and in the case of Derrybrien, a bog landslide. Perhaps this comment will be difficult for many to accept, but the old Irish proverb "the truth is often harsh" should be not overlooked.

Posted by: ciaran graham at November 7, 2003 08:25 PM

It is in peoples nature to blame the obvious. The radar aviation station was said to be the cause of the landslide in Pollatomas. However the consultancy firm acting on behalf of Mayo County Council have came to the conclusion that the very dry summer coupled with the heavy rainfall on the night in question was the actual cause.
Windfarm development in this country is of extreme importance and benifit to the environment, I just wish people would look at the bigger picture.

Posted by: Dominick Gallagher at November 12, 2003 01:44 PM

i think the main cause of this BOG BURST WAS THE PEOPLE AT THE WIND FARM CLEARING AWAY TREES TO MAKE THE WIND FARMS THEREFORE THERE WERE NO OTHER WAYS OF SOAKING UP THE WATER.SO THE BOG BECAME OVER SATURATED AND STARTED TO SLIDE. ANOTHER REASON TO ADD TO THE GOVERMENTS INCOMPTENTCY!!!

Posted by: evan at November 15, 2003 12:13 PM

I am extremely concerned about the damage peat suffers at the hands of wind energy development in these remote areas. I live most of the time in Sutherland where we have over 1oo clusters threatening our precious wild land here in the Highlands of Scotland. please share any findings etc if possible. Best wishes
Hazel

Posted by: Hazel Macmillan at December 23, 2003 02:22 PM